Tuesday, July 18, 2006

Wth!!

What's happening!! I found it so unbelievable when I first heard about it. I thought it was probably a joke. Turns out the joke is on us, all of us, and our rights.. our freedoms! are we living in a democracy or a dictatorship??

12 sites on Govt gag list

2 sites on Govt gag listThe government has instructed Internet Service Providers (ISPs) to block 12 websites. The order has come in the wake of the Mumbai bomb blasts, and these websites are perceived to be anti-India. Unfortunately, one of these is blogger or blogspot.com, a Google affiliated site which hosts millions of blogs worldwide.

Sources in the government said that a circular was issued by the Home Affairs Ministry three days back asking the Ministry of Information and Technology to block the 12 websites which posted content maligning India. Hundreds of netizens tried unsuccessfully to log on to blogger.com on Monday. These bloggers exchanged flash messages to discover that none of them were being able to log on to the website.

Officials defended the decision saying, "We would like those people to come forward who access these (the 12) radical websites and please explain to us what are they missing from their lives in the absence of these sites."

More information here

And make sure you check this out. Ways to bypass the ban.

I still don't believe it. Does freedom of speech and expression really even exist in this country? I'm a lawyer, and right now I feel like the law is just a puppet in the hands of this government. We could probably say this is a violation of our fundamental right to freedom of speech and expression, this is total censorship.. Yes, the government can restrict this freedom. (Read this article of the constitution for details.) The government can basically put 'reasonable restrictions' on this right. Reasonable Restrictions! what on earth made them do this..

Right to Freedom
19. Protection of certain rights regarding freedom of speech, etc.-

(1) All citizens shall have the right-

(a) to freedom of speech and expression;

[(2) Nothing in sub-clause (a) of clause (1) shall affect the operation of any existing law, or prevent the State from making any law, in so far as such law imposes reasonable restrictions on the exercise of the right conferred by the said sub-clause in the interests of [the sovereignty and integrity of India,] the security of the State, friendly relations with foreign States, public order, decency or morality, or in relation to contempt of court, defamation or incitement to an offence.]



Today they have blogged blogspot, tomorrow they'll block news, email.. what not!! are we going to let this happen?

And I don't understand.. y just blogger? there r so many other blog sites..and so many other ways to bypass these bans.. it's just totally absurd!! Blogs r public sites..anyone can access them.. how could the terrorists use them!!

21 comments:

teacup said...

this just makes me laugh...totally ridiculous! I don't know wat they were thinkin...wat is funny is that there are so many ways in which we can access blogs...am sure if we can find waays to access then these terrorists could too! doesn't the govt realise this??

Harry said...

dis is the height of thinking...
i feel is the govt sitting in the centre to proclaim such stupid observations??
i totally agree what yashita has thought that if can find ways to access then these terrosrists could too...
shame on the Indian Govt which dream of the developed India and back on the home,they pass such orders...ridiculous.....

Anonymous said...

Well, for all those who wanted to become like China (more specificallt, Mumbai like Shanghai, and all that stuff.) ... Here's more like China for you....

jhantu said...

interesting blog but "how could terrorists use it" seems a bit too naive a line in conclusion

Keshi said...

**Does freedom of speech and expression really even exist in this country

it seems that democracy is only a term these days.

Also I heard that the ban will be lifted in 48hrs :)

Keshi.

ishipishi said...

tell it like it is Neha...everyone needs to write and blog about this! I did what i could...right from using the national media (Thank God for them) to what i do best...blog about it!...

and the ban i hear is off in some plcs...i got a comment in my blog right now that some ISP's have fixed the issue...

mine's not workin yet...still blocked...and m making life hell for my ISP!:))

I've said all that i have to in my post...phew...and I will go on about this till the ban's off everywhere!

tc..!

Abhishek said...

this ban has no concrete reason...
can anything be dont abt this?

Sudarshan said...

Arre neha..they're behaving like utter fools.

They should learn how to handle this terrorist menace from other countries rather than doing such outrageous crap..I pity such losers!!!

anyway they've repealed the ban..there's still some sense left..I'm glad..

Hope they don't commit such foolish acts in the future!!

Abhishek said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
manu_the_lawgiver said...

Read this article yesterday in d newspaper and then came to know why i wasnt being able to acess any of d blogspot sites. Echo ur sentiments.Tc:)

Anand said...

Hey dont worry..apparently the ban has been lifted now!!..so we are still connected!

SeePearrl said...

Gud that they have revoked their decision on blocking hte blogs by just saying it as a technical error with blogspot domain...

really shame on them!
they cant even accept wat they have done!

Sudeep said...

I hope u can access it now.. i cant access blogspot frm home till now :(
btw, join the blue ribbon campaign.. details on my post.. it is for stopping censorship on blogs
have a nice weekend.. sunday is back ;)

Anirudh 'Lallan' Choudhry said...

tadaaaaa... i feel so happy...m so must b u...i tol ya na ma blog bloced..i eman our...it felt like we have lost relatives...feelin so gud again..!

Anonymous said...

Finally, the ban is gone..
and hopefully, there won't be another fiasco like this one

Abhishek said...

now that the bans over.think its time u posted new stuff :)

Rupali_Srivastava said...

You know I was not all that upset about the ban.In US Myspace is under severe criticism because of it's alleged misuse.I saw a program once about a girl who used to regularly visit a site that shared tips about how to suicide and she actually killed herself.Her dad was upset as to why the law and order does not do anything against such sites.

When things go wrong we blame the govt. But we must realise that uneasy is the head that wears the crown.

Nice to be back though

The Individualist said...

Ankush,
I had called in my ISP and they had advised me that 'it was as per the advise of the government that they were blocking the website.'

Anyway, the whole thing is comical. The logic behind the applied blocks and the severity of the actions taken and the issues on which the actions were taken. I've spoken enough about it actually. So much so that some website actually published some of my rants.
Anyway. Feels good to be back. Ahem. And by the way, the blocks have now been removed as well. So, cheers. Even though, it still pricks to think that they blocked it in the first place.

catch 22 said...

I never understood why it was blocked and why it has been lifted now.
Job seems to be keeping u real busy :)

Whats In A Name said...

Hey,

Does the Right to Freedom you mentioned in your blog mean that mean we arent even blessed with rights to shout our hearts out against such nerds? When do they consider a person is doing defamamtion or an ofence??
Doesnt it have an ambiguity factor involved in it??

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.